let me share with you all the mascaras i've used too!

+

+
Maybelline Mini-brush mascara(water resistant)
As the name suggests, the brush is really small and very easy to use. One of my favorites!
But don't expect dramatic lengthening/voluming effects, cuz it's just a regular mascara with GOOD brush.
I usually use this first and use something else.
Fasio power-stay 3D + air tech curl long(waterproof)
the brush is designed like a comb, so ur eyelashes wouldn't clump/stick together. But it may take some time to get used to becuz of the contour, so i ended up coloring my eye lids the first few tries.
voluminsing+lengthening effect... hmm.. not too bad.
Kate enamel glow mascara.
(waterproof)
it's supposed to be a volumising mascara, but it works like any regular mascara. Not fantastic.
I think it clumps easily too.. or it may just be my imagination. cuz i don't use it as regularly.
Missha Viewer 270degrees(no idea if it's waterproof or not.. but i highly doubt it though. heh.)
VERY GOOD.

even without a base coat, i could see my eyelashes grow longer and thicker somewhat.
dejavu Fiber wigi second Cheeky_devil.. to me, this is no good..
====================================================
polo, if you want something which can washed off easily, how about trying the Maybelline mini lash? It comes out very fast becuz it's only water resistant.
i remembered reading some girls saying that their mascara smudges at the botton of their eye, despite using waterproof mascaras?
This is because mascaras are waterproof, they're never oil-proof.
(if it's oil-proof, then u'll have a hard time removing cuz our eye-makeup remover is an oil+water solution).
So when it comes into contact with ur eye cream which contains oil, it'll smudge.